Stuffed Shells recipe~ Manicotti Recipe – COOKING WITH WHAT IS IN THE PANTRY

06/25/2016 8:00 am · 129 comments

by Sarah A Thrifty Mom

Stuffed Shells recipe

Quick and Easy Cheese Manicotti Pasta dinner recipe

Easy Dinner Ideas, Easy Freezer Meals, Stuffed Shells are a great way to feel a large group with no stressThis is a recipe re-post…. I posted this recipe 3 years ago but recently had a request to post it again.  Hope you enjoy this money saving recipe.

IMG_1985

I decided to cook some Pasta for my family.  To be honest if I am going to eat pasta I prefer home made Alfredo Sauce, but I know that red sauce it good for you. Plus I got it for free so it is a thrifty way to feed my family.  This recipe is one that my whole family loves, and we normally keep all the ingredients in the pantry or freezer.

IMG_1949So I went to my pantry and I had two opened boxes of pasta, both half empty I wanted to use them up.  I used them both to make the same meal with a twist.

IMG_1953

Start your pasta cooking first, (while it cooks you can mix the filling for the shells). I needed to cook both kinds of pasta but the shells need to cook for 5 min longer, so I brought the water to a boil.  Added the shells,  then 5 mins later added the noodles.IMG_1957Add them to the boiling water, they will soften up and slide into the water.  Do not try to push them in or they might break.  Cook according to the box direction.  Do not over cook or they will be mushy, because you need to bake them to.

IMG_1958

Pour your noodles into a strainer so all the hot water drains off. Then  rinse them with cold water so they will be cool enough to handle.  If you are not going to fill them right away you will need to toss a little oil on them and separate them out on wax paper so they will not stick together.

Cheese filling mixture

IMG_1951

In a bowl add:

  • 1 package of ricotta cheese 16 oz
  • 1 1/2 cup of parmesan cheese (1/2 cup set aside for top)
  • 2 cups of mozzarella cheese grated
  • 1 large egg
  • 1/2 teaspoon salt
  • 1/4 teaspoon black pepper
  • dash  or 1/8 teaspoon grated nutmeg ( sound wierd but really makes it good)
  • 2 tablespoons parsley fresh or dry

IMG_1952Mix till well blended.  Now here is the twist, normally you would just use one box of pasta shells and fill them all.  But I wanted to use up both boxes of pasta so I just made half shells and half cheesy roll ups.

IMG_1960

Take a large scoop of filling and fill the cooked  shell.

IMG_1964Place the shell, cheese side up on a pan with pasta sauce in the bottom.

IMG_1967Now you can use the same filling to make Cheesy roll ups. Spread the filling out in a thin flat layer over the noodle.  Leave the last inch open so the noolde will stick together in the roll.

IMG_1966Roll it up….

IMG_1968

This is what it should look like.  Place seam side down in a pan, with pasta sauce on the bottom.

IMG_1959

Pour your jar of pasta sauce into one large 11×13 pan or you can split it up and pour half into two smaller pans.  I always use two smaller pans, and put one in the freezer.

IMG_1969

Add another 1/2 cup of parmesan on the top

IMG_1973

Cover them both with foil, I put one in the freezer.  Bake the other in a 350 degree oven for 35 mins, take foil off and bake for another 10 mins. ( for a total of 45 mins)

IMG_1979

If you want to change it up a bit you can add, spinach or cooked sausage to the cheese mixture.  My family really enjoys this, hopes yours will too.

You can watch us make it LIVE here

Disclaimer: This post may or may not contain affiliate links.
SUBSCRIBE and never miss a thing!
Disclaimer and Official Rules for Sweepstakes

Leave a Comment: 129 comments

Filed Under: Casseroles, Food Storage Recipes, Main / Dinner / Supper, Recipes, Red Meat

Tags: , , , , , ,

136 comments
A Thrifty Mom
A Thrifty Mom

Here was the final results.... STUFFED SHELLS thanks to everyone who watched!

Kay Langdon
Kay Langdon

I love 2 use just a lol cayenne pepper 2 gives it a great bite

Megan Farris
Megan Farris

I want to make stress balls with my preschool students

Megan Farris
Megan Farris

Yayyy can't wait to watch the girls! I want to make stress balls with

Kay Langdon
Kay Langdon

Enjoy have a great evening c u next time

Adell Davis
Adell Davis

Now I know about this I will follow!

Megan Farris
Megan Farris

I love that ball of energy in the background!

Vita Kay
Vita Kay

I'm low too on vit D! Gotta get out there and get some sun!! \U0001f31e

Adell Davis
Adell Davis

Vitamin d is essential for mental health!

Kay Langdon
Kay Langdon

Shed doing pretty good @ stretching it out

Adell Davis
Adell Davis

I would serve green beans with garlic and olive oil

Kay Langdon
Kay Langdon

Salad & garlic bread would b perfect

Adell Davis
Adell Davis

I use tooth picks to tent my foil over cheese dishes, works great.

Kay Langdon
Kay Langdon

Have u ever had chocolate cobbler yummmmm

Melissa Hale-Hudgeons
Melissa Hale-Hudgeons

My 6 year old is going to have lots of fun making this tomorrow! Thank you for sharing!!

Kay Langdon
Kay Langdon

I add ricotta cheese my Alfredo sauce

Kay Langdon
Kay Langdon

A Dell that's all I use is homemade Alfredo sauce its so much better on stomach lol

Previous post:

Next post: